MIES (Switzerland) - Experts analyze all BCL games each week. In order to improve the understanding of referees' decisions and to increase transparency, we publish some of those Tough Calls, along with an explanation.
TC1: Bnei Penlink Herzliya vs. Telekom Baskets Bonn - Backcourt violation
Pink #11 attempts a three-point shot. The ball hits the ring, and Pink #12 taps it towards his team’s backcourt.
Pink #1 gains control of the ball and starts dribbling.
Article 30.2: A team which is in control of a live ball in its frontcourt may not cause the ball to be illegally returned to its backcourt.
Article 30.1.2: A team in control of a live ball in the frontcourt has illegally returned the ball to its backcourt, if a player of that team is the last to touch the ball in the frontcourt and the ball is then first touched by a player of that team:
Who has part of the body in contact with the backcourt, or
After the ball has touched the backcourt of that team.
Article 14.1.3: Team control ends when:
An opponent gains control.
The ball becomes dead.
The ball has left the player's hand(s) on a shot for a goal or for a free throw.
Article 14.1.1: Team control starts when a player of that team is in control of a live ball by holding or dribbling it or has a live ball at a player’s disposal.
Outcome: Correct decision by the referees.
The Pink team loses the control of the ball when Pink #11 releases the ball for the shot. Pink #12’s tap of the ball does not establish a new team control, as he neither holds the ball nor dribbles it.
New team control is established when Pink #1 starts dribbling in his backcourt. Legal play.
TC2: Asisa Joventut vs. FC Porto - Flagrant foul
Black #10 receives the ball. White #10 makes illegal contact, and the referees call a personal foul on White #10. After a brief discussion, the referees decide to use the IRS to review if the contact by White should be upgraded to a flagrant foul.
Article 38.1.1: A flagrant foul is a player’s illegal contact with an opponent, which violates the spirit of sportsmanship and fair play, and by its nature and/or the severity level exceeds the limits of a personal or disruptive foul. The criteria for flagrant fouls are the following:
Not a legitimate basketball play against an opponent, with or without a ball.
Outcome: The initial decision by the referees was incorrect but was corrected following the IRS review. The contact by White #10 meets one of the criteria for a flagrant foul.
Black #10 shall be awarded two free throws and the game shall resume with a Black team throw-in from the throw-in line in its frontcourt, with 14 seconds displayed on the shot clock.
TC3: Unicaja vs. BK KVIS Pardubice - Flagrant foul
Green #55 starts dribbling towards the frontcourt, guarded by White #7. Contact occurs, and the referee calls a team control foul on Green #55.
Article 38.1.1: A flagrant foul is a player’s illegal contact with an opponent, which violates the spirit of sportsmanship and fair play, and by its nature and/or the severity level exceeds the limits of a personal or disruptive foul. The criteria for flagrant fouls are the following:
Excessive, hard contact in an effort to play the ball or an opponent.
Outcome: Incorrect decision by the referee.
The contact created by Green #55 with his elbow meets one of the criteria for a flagrant foul. White #7 should be awarded two free throws and the game should resume with a White team throw-in from the throw-in line in its frontcourt, with 14 seconds displayed on the shot clock.
TC4: AEK BC vs. Falco-Vulcano Szombathely - Alternating possession
The 4th quarter is about to start with a Black team alternating possession throw-in. The referee calls a team control foul on Black #4.
After reporting the foul, the game clock is reset to 10:00 and the alternating possession arrow is reversed in favor of the Yellow team.
The game continues, and at the next dead ball, with the game clock stopped, the Technical Delegate informs the referees that the alternating possession arrow should not have been reversed but should have remained in favor of the Black team.
Article 12.4: A jump ball situation occurs when:
All quarters other than the first quarter and all overtimes are to start
Article 12.6.3: The team entitled to the next alternating possession at the end of any quarter or overtime shall start the next quarter or overtime with a throw-in from the centre line extended, opposite the scorer’s table, unless there are further free throws and a possession penalty to be administered.
Article 12.6.4: The team entitled to the alternating possession throw-in shall be indicated by the alternating possession arrow in the direction of the opponents’ basket. The direction of the alternating possession arrow shall be reversed immediately when the alternating possession throw-in ends.
Article 17.1.2: A throw-in ends when:
The ball touches or is legally touched by any player on the court.
The team of the thrower-in commits a violation.
A live ball lodges between the ring and the backboard during a throw-in.
Article 12.6.6: A foul by either team:
Before the start of a quarter other than the first quarter or an overtime, or
During the alternating possession throw-in, does not cause the team entitled to the throw-in to lose that alternating possession.
Outcome: First, incorrect decision by the referee, as the contact by Black #4 should not have been called as a foul.
However, once the foul has been called, it is important to note that it occurred before the alternating possession throw-in had ended, as the ball had not been legally touched on the court by any player.
Therefore, the alternating possession arrow should not be reversed, and the eventual next alternating possession throw-in shall be awarded to the Black team.
Final correct decision by the officiating crew.